Making conversation...

A typical stream of...interaction between me and Tatum
T: (after a dr's appt to check for ear infection) Why did Tennison get a shot?
M: He didn't get a shot
T: But why did he?
M: Why did he what?
T: Huh?!

Here is another one...
T: What day is the reunion?
M: Reunion has already passed
T: But what day is it?
M: The day has already gone, we've been to reunion already
T: I guess you won't tell me

I wonder who really has the problem, Tatum or me?